WHIP vs ERA
There are various statistics used to analyze the game of baseball and all of the athletes who play this sport. These statistics can be used for multiple purposes, such as determining batting order, deciding who will play in a particular game, and rating players. Two of the most critical statistics in baseball are WHIP and ERA. Both of these statistics are used to evaluate the performances of pitchers. Though they measure different aspects of a pitcher's performance, they are both critical in their ways.
What is the WHIP Statistic?
The WHIP statistic measures how many walks and hits a pitcher allows in an inning. One of the primary duties of a pitcher is to keep runners from getting on base, and therefore, this statistic is extremely useful in evaluating a pitcher's effectiveness. This statistic can be calculated by summing the walks and hits conceded by a pitcher and dividing that number by the number of innings pitched. For example, if a pitcher concedes 260 hits and 260 walks in 480 innings, their WHIP will be 1.083333 (260+260=520 520/480=1.083333). Because WHIP measures how frequently pitchers allow batters to get on base, pitchers with lower WHIPs are typically considered more talented.
The best pitchers in Major League Baseball typically have a seasonal WHIP of around 1. The lowest ever WHIP for a single season was recorded by Pedro Martinez of the Boston Red Sox in 2000. Martinez registered an extremely impressive WHIP of .7373, meaning that for every inning he pitched, Martinez only allowed .7373 runners to reach base. The record for the lowest career WHIP is .9678 and is held by Addie Joss, a right-handed pitcher who played for the Cleveland Bronchos (now known as the Cleveland Indians) between 1902 and 1910.
What is the ERA Statistic?
The ERA (Earned Run Average) statistic measures the number of earned runs conceded by a pitcher every nine innings. An earned run can be defined as a run that was scored without contributing an error by the team in the field. An ERA is the most commonly used statistic in evaluating pitchers' effectiveness and is one of the most important statistics in the game of baseball. It can be calculated by dividing the number of earned runs conceded by a pitcher by the number of innings that they pitched and multiplying that number by nine (, or however many innings you are in the game if you are not playing a standard-length baseball game). For example, if a pitcher conceded 140 runs in 480 innings, their Earned Run Average would be 2.625 (140x9=1,260 1,260/480=2.625). Because pitchers want to prevent their opponents from scoring, their goal is to have as low of an ERA as possible.
The record for ERA in modern Major League Baseball is held by Ed Walsh, who played for the Chicago White Sox and the Boston Red Sox between 1904 and 1917. Walsh boasted an extremely impressive career ERA of 1.82. Dutch Leonard, who played for the Detroit Tigers and the Boston Red Sox, holds the record for the lowest single-season ERA in modern Major League Baseball with a .96 in 1914. However, in 1920 Major League Baseball changed some of its rules, which led to more runs being scored. Two of these rule changes include the abolition of the spitball and replacing baseballs when they become scuffed. Because of these rules, pitchers who played after 1920 typically have higher ERAs than those before 1920. The post-1920 ERA leader is Mariano Rivera, who played for the New York Yankees between 1995 and 2013. Rivera had a career ERA of 2.21.
Benefits of Using the WHIP Statistic:
The primary goal is to keep batters from reaching base, and the WHIP statistic measures their effectiveness in achieving this goal. When a batter comes bottom, they are more likely to score, and, as such, teams want to put pitchers on the mound who allow very few batters to get on the basepath. Though the primary purpose of the WHIP statistic is to predict how many batters will reach base in any given inning, this statistic can also indirectly tell us more about a pitcher's game. For example, pitchers with higher WHIPs allow more hits and walks, and, as such, they also must throw more pitches. As a result, they are more likely to become fatigued earlier in games or earlier in the season. Though fatigue and pitching outings were not what the WHIP statistic was designed to measure, it can indirectly predict these factors.
Additionally, many individuals argue that the WHIP is the most accurate measure of a pitcher's performance. If a pitcher walks a batter or allows them to get a hit, they are directly responsible for this - not anyone else on their team. However, if an opposing player scores a run, this could have occurred due to the action of an outfield player. Even if the run was an earned run, it is possible that the defense was partially responsible for the run.
Drawbacks of Using the WHIP Statistic:
Though understanding the frequency with which pitchers allow runners to get on base is essential, it is arguably not the best way to evaluate a pitcher's performance. A pitcher could allow several hits and walks and still not concede any runs. Though WHIP and runs conceded are usually positively correlated, this is not always the case. Another drawback of the WHIP statistic is that it values how a player can get on base equally. For example, suppose a pitcher allows two singles and a walk in an inning. In that case, they will have the same WHIP as a pitcher who conceded two doubles and a triple in an inning, which is not necessarily reflective of the quality of their performances.
Benefits of Using the ERA Statistic:
Though it is essential to measure how many runners a pitcher allows to reach base, what wins or loses a baseball game is the number of runs scored. Even if a team loads the floors in every inning, they cannot beat the game if they do not score runs. Alternatively, even if a pitcher allows players to get on base every inning, they will not lose the game if they do not concede any runs. You would rather have a pitcher on your team who concedes more walks and hits but fewer runs than a pitcher who concedes more minor hits and walks but more runs.
Drawbacks of Using the ERA Statistic:
An ERA is not necessarily the most accurate way to measure a pitcher's performance. If a batter scores a run, even if it is earned, the defense's version could also be partially to blame. If a fielder does not react fast enough or make an accurate throw, an opposing player could score. Even though this action would not be counted as an error, it was due to a player's actions in the field, not the pitcher, that the run was allowed to score.
Should You Focus on WHIP or ERA?
The honest answer to this question is that there is no correct answer. We believe that the WHIP statistic and the ERA statistic are most accurate when used together, as they both highlight different aspects of a pitcher's game. In many situations, WHIP can predict ERA, and they are positively correlated. If a pitcher allows many batters to reach base, they will likely give up more earned runs during their outings than pitchers who enable fewer opponents to reach base. In many cases, if the WHIP statistic or the ERA statistic were evaluated on its own, it would not tell the whole story. For instance, a pitcher may concede several walks without conceding many runs. Though it is important to note that they let many batters get on base, we should also keep in mind that they do not let opposing teams score often.
Additionally, a pitcher may concede three runs off of three home runs. Though this is significant to consider, this is very different from allowing three runs by allowing all of the players who scored to get on base and then other players to hit RBIs. At the end of the day, though both the WHIP statistic and the ERA statistic are essential, they only tell part of the story, and as such, they should be used in tandem if you want to understand the quality of a pitcher truly.
Though there are many statistics in baseball, two of the most important are the WHIP statistic and the ERA statistic. These statistics are both used to evaluate different aspects of a pitcher's game. Both WHIP and ERA have a lot of benefits, but some downfalls, as well. Ultimately, if you want to evaluate a pitcher's game and predict their performances with the most accuracy, you should utilize and examine both of these statistics. We hope that this article was helpful if you are interested in the statistics used to analyze the game of baseball.
If you enjoyed reading this blog and find similar articles, feel free to check out Ryan Weiss Baseball.